Thursday, October 1, 2026

CAN ANYTHING GOOD COME OUT OF HOLLYWOOD? - Donald Bingham

I recently purchased a little (5 1/2" x 9 1/2") hard cover book entitled "Can Anything Good Come Out of Hollywood?"  



It was published in 1923 by Snyder Publications, Hollywood Security Building, Hollywood, California.  It's a small book (64 pages), and profusely illustrated with photos of local citizens and organizations touting the many people and places that make Hollywood a great place to live and work.

If you want to read it yourself, a free copy is available online at: 



A copy of the book was donated to the Internet Archive by my good friend, the late Joe Yranski.  

The interesting thing about my copy of this particular volume is that it was inscribed:



"Can Anything Good Come Out of Hollywood?" - Come and See - To Aunt Alice from Donald Bingham.

I decided that it might be interesting to see what we could "dig up" about Donald and Aunt Alice to see if they ever did live in Hollywood and if their lives were "Good."  I'll tell you what I uncovered about them and let you draw your own conclusions.

First I had to find Donald Bingham.  I started with ancestry.com, looking for a Donald Bingham in or near Hollywood in or near 1923.  

The "Search" function brought me to a World War I draft registration card for a Donald Bingham who lived in Kern County, California.  When I looked at the way he wrote his name on the draft card, I could see that it was the same handwriting on the inscription in the book.  Take a look:





Obviously the same handwriting on both, so we know we have found our Donald Bingham.  From the draft registration card we find that He was born in Portersville, California on July 5, 1893; that in 1918 he was working for the General Petroleum Company and that he was living and working in Beleridge, California.  These facts lead us to the rest of the story of Donald Bingham.

Donald Bingham was born July 5, 1893 in Portersville, California to Frank Milford Bingham (1865-1932) and Elizabeth "Libby" Long Bingham (1864-1897). Frank Bingham was a carpenter by trade.  Frank and Elizabeth had married in Iantha, Missouri on November 21, 1886.  They were blessed with four sons:  Frank Overton Bingham (1887-1960), Ora Lee Brigham (1889-1968), Augusta Gay Brigham (1892-1942), and Donald Bingham (1893-1924).

Donald's mother Libbie Bingham died in April of 1897 in Porterville, California.  She was thirty-three years old.  Here is her Death Notice from the Visalia (CA) Morning Delta from April 27, 1897:



She is buried in an unmarked grave in the Porterville Cemetery, Porterville, California:

Courtesy of Find a Grave Volunteer Henry Webber






















The 1900 US Census finds Donald Bingham living with his father and family in Exeter Township, Tulare County, California.  The family consisted of:  Frank Bingham (36 years old), his (2nd) wife Minnie (32), four sons: Ovey F. Bingham (12), Ora L. Bingham (11), Guy A. Bingham (9), and Donald (6), and one daughter, Ida May (1).  Frank and Minnie said they had been married two years.  Minnie said she had given birth to one child, and that child was still alive in 1900.  Frank said his occupation was "Carpenter."  Lastly, the Binghams reported that they lived in a house, and that they owned it free and clear.

The 1910 US Census finds Donald living as a Boarder at 1937 Sacramento Street in Los Angeles.  An industrial building occupies that site today.  He said he was sixteen years old.  He listed his Occupation as "Teamster in Construction."  He could, of course, read and write.

The 1911 Directory for Los Angeles, California shows Donald living at 1400 East 8th Street in Los Angeles.  A truck terminal occupies that spot today.  Perhaps in 1911 some truck drivers were allowed to live at the truck terminal.  

In November of 1912, Donald Bingham registered a motor vehicle with the State of California.  When he did this, he gave his address as 318 Crocker Street, Los Angeles.  It is listed as a "light manufacturing" site today but it is possible it was residential in 1912:




Unfortunately this is now considered part of Skid Row in LA.

In the 1914 Directory for Los Angeles, we find Donald is now living at 1638 East 23rd Street in LA.  An industrial building occupies that plot today.  The Directory listed his occupation as "Teamster."  

As mentioned above, Donald registered for the Draft on June 5, 1917.  He gave his address as "Beleridge, McKittrick, California."  He gave his occupation as "Teamster - Oil Work" for the General Petroleum Company in Beleridge.  The facility is located within the prolific Kern County oil fields. This facility processes natural gas extracted alongside crude oil and generates cogenerated electricity, supporting enhanced oil recovery and local energy needs.

According to the Registrar, Bingham was Single, Tall and Slender, with Blue eyes and Black hair, and at one time had suffered a broken wrist.  

I could not find Donald Bingham in the 1920 US Census.  I did find an "August" Bingham who was a Truck Driver in McKittrick but none of the other information lines up with Donald.

On a happier note, Donald Bingham married Frankie Bernice Stubblefield (1903-1974) on November 16, 1920 in Kern, California.  The groom was twenty-seven; the bride was seventeen.

The Fresno (CA) Morning Republican - 16 Nov 1920


Frankie Bernice Stubblefield was born February 28, 1903 in Bakersfield, California to Robert A. Stubblefield (1862-1913) and Katherine E. Ramey (1871-1940).  Robert and Katherine had married in 1887 in Pine Grove, California.  They were blessed with eleven (!) children: Jesse Luther Stubblefield (1887-1953), Nellie May Stubblefield/Mrs. John H. Kerr/Mrs. Herbert Aspittle (1890-1979), Ruth Hazel Stubblefield/Mrs. George C. Rascoe/Mrs. Harry W. Bonner/Mrs. Rudolph J. Seehuber (1896-1944), Alta Stubblefield/Mrs. Roland R. Baker (1898-1928), Grace Maud Stubblefield/Mrs. Oliver C. Sprague (1900-1986), Frankie Bernice Stubblefield/Mrs. Donald Bingham/Mrs. Roland R. Baker (1903-1974), Robert Stubblefield (1905-1907), Katheryn Stubblefield/Mrs. Henry C. Noles (1908-1967), Kenneth Alston Stubblefield (1908-1969), and twins Annie (1910-1910) and Rosa Stubblefield (1910-1913).  Frankie's father Robert was a prospector for mica.

Donald Bingham died March 29, 1924 in Inglewood, California.  He was thirty years old.  The Cause of Death was Pulmonary Tuberculosis with Appendicitis as a contributing factor.  Here is his Death Certificate:


Here is his Death Notice from the Los Angeles Times from March 30, 1924:


He was buried in the Inglewood Park Cemetery in Inglewood:




The Death Certificate says that Bingham was "Divorced."

You will remember that at the beginning of this article I said that I had purchased a book called "Can Anything Good Come Out of Hollywood?" that had been inscribed by Donald Bingham to "Aunt Alice."  After extensive research I could not find anyone in Donald Bingham's family tree named "Alice."  I put together an extensive Family Tree for Bingham that contained 85 people.  I listed all of Donald's siblings and their spouses, and all of the descendants of Frank Milford Bingham, plus all of Frankie Stubblefield's siblings and their spouses and there was not one "Alice" in the bunch.


Perhaps they were not related at all.  My brother and sister-in-law had the annoying habit of having their children call all of their friends "Aunt So and So," or "Uncle So and So" even when they were not related.

So, the "Aunt Alice" to whom Donald Bingham inscribed the book will have to remain a mystery. 

Furthermore, it does not appear that Donald Bingham ever lived in Hollywood himself.

So, when Donald Bingham asked "Can anything good come out of Hollywood?"  we don't know what his answer would have been.  May he rest in peace.






THE REST OF THE STORY

Frank Milford Bingham (1865-1932), Donald's father.  After his first wife Libbie died in 1897, Frank married two more times.  He married Millie Eleanora Berry (1867-1946) in 1898, and Eleanor Margaret Hurley (1876-1953) in 1912.  In addition to the four sons he had with Libbie, he went on to father four more children.  He had one daughter with Minnie and two sons and a daughter with Eleanor.  Although he had been raised Protestant, he became a Catholic when he married Eleanor.  Frank Bingham died January 29, 1932 at the age of eighty-six.  Here is his Death Notice from the Santa Ana (CA) Register from January 31, 1932:


Despite the Death Notice saying he would be buried in the Santa Ana Cemetery, he is actually buried in the Holy Sepulcher Cemetery in Orange, California.  Here is a photo of his tombstone:

Courtesy of Find a Grave Volunteer Kimberley Terrill


Frankie Bernice Stubblefield Bingham (1903-1974), Donald's ex-wife.  Donald's Death Certificate indicated that he was divorced at the time of his death in 1924.  Frankie remarried in 1933 to Roland Russel Baker (1895-1964).  Frankie and Roland Baker did not have any children, but Baker had three children from a previous marriage.  Frankie Bernice Stubblefield Bingham Baker died on November 8, 1974 in Bakersfield, California.  She was seventy-one years old.  Here is her obituary from the local newspaper:


She was buried in the Kern River Valley Cemetery, Wofford Heights, California.  Here is her tombstone:



No comments:

Post a Comment