THE HOTEL MONNETT IN EVANSTON, ILLINOIS - Elmira Monnett and her brother Fletcher Monnett

Frequent readers of this blog know that I have always loved hotels.  I don't know why, but the hustle and bustle, the transient nature of the guests and the historic buildings have always been fascinating to me.  I am especially interested in the hotels of my home town, Evanston, Illinois.  I have written in the past in this blog about the Orrington Hotel, and an upcoming article will tell the history of the Hotel Evanston (or Evanston Inn as it was sometimes known). 

I recently received an email from Find a Grave asking me to add information to the memorial page of Watson Ludlam, the son of Dr. Jacob Watson Ludlam of Evanston.  You may remember that I had previously written about Dr. Ludlam, who was the first person buried at Rosehill Cemetery:

https://undereverytombstone.blogspot.com/2012/12/the-first-burial-at-rosehill-cemetery.html

I looked up the death record for Watson Ludlam and it said that when he died on April 30, 1912 that he had been living at the "Monatte Hotel" in Evanston.  That was an Evanston hotel that I had never heard of so I was intrigued.  I reached out to my friend and researcher extraordinaire Mike Kelly and asked him if he had ever heard of the Monatte Hotel.  I have mentioned before that Mike is an incredible depository of facts about the history of Evanston.  In the meantime I did some more digging myself.  I Googled "Monatte Hotel" and nothing came up.  The same with newspapers.com - nothing for Monatte Hotel.  Then I took a look in the Evanston Directory for 1912 and here's what I found:

I have mentioned that I used to work for Washington National Insurance Company in Evanston - the address of the Home Office was 1630 Chicago Avenue.  So if the Monnett Hotel was at 1633 Chicago Avenue that means it was on the east side of the street near the intersection of Church Street and Chicago Avenue.  After finding out that the name of the hotel was misspelled in the Death Record, I continued my search looking for the correctly spelled Hotel Monnett.  Google directed me to the Internet Archive which had 64 results for the hotel.  There were results from several different sources, but most of them were listings from the various Evanston Directories of the time from 1890-1922.  

The 1895 Evanston Directory listed the Hotel Monnett at Church Street and Chicago Avenue and the proprietor as Elmira Monnett.  In addition the directory listed six other people as living at the hotel.  This lead me to believe that the Hotel Monnett was more of an apartment hotel than a transient hotel.  In doing my research for this article I found a clipping from the Evanston Review that said that Northwestern University president (and Leighton Mount nemesis) Walter Dill Scott lived at the Hotel Monnett for 30 years.  Further research, however found that while many people lived at the Hotel Monnett for extended periods, Walter Dill Scott was not one of them.  

During the years she owned the hotel, Elmira Monnett often lived elsewhere and her brother Fletcher Monnett managed the hotel for her and inherited it after Elmira died.  In fact, the Monnett hotel would provide a life-changing experience for Fletcher Monnett - so, let's see what we can "dig up" first about Elmira Monnett, and then about her brother Fletcher Monnett.

Elmira Monnett was born on May 27, 1843 in Ohio, the daughter of Thomas Jefferson Monnett (1810-1890) and Mary Delamer Kinnear (1815-1880).  Elmira Monnett's father Thomas was both a farmer and a Wesleyan Methodist minister by trade.  In addition to Elmira, Thomas and Mary Monnett had three other children:  Cordellia Pittenger Monnett (1836-1910), Fletcher F. Monnett (1838-1910), and Lucinda Monnett (1841-1906).  Here's a drawing of Elmira's father Thomas Monnett:

a photo of Elmira's mother, Mary Delamer Kinnear Monnett:

Mary Delamer Kinnear Monnett

And a photo of Elmira's sister, Cordellia Monnett:

Cordellia Monnett

Unfortunately I have been unable to find a photo of Elmira herself.

An interesting side note:  Elmira's sister Cordellia went on to become a Deaconess in the Methodist Church - more about that later.

The first mention of Elmira Monnett is in the 1850 US Census when she was 7 years old (referenced as "Almira").  The Monnett family is living in Bucyrus, Ohio where Thomas Monnett is listed as a "Farmer."  In addition to Elmira and her father, the census also lists her mother Mary and siblings Cordellia, Fletcher and Lucinda.  Thomas told the census taker his farm was worth $4,000.

By the 1860 US Census the Monnett family had relocated to Rensselaer, Indiana.  The family consisted of  Thomas and Mary, and children Fletcher (21 years old), Cordellia (23 years old), Lucinda (19 years old) and Elmira (17 years old).  In addition there were two laborers, George W. Dutcher and Horace James living with the Monnetts.  Thomas and Fletcher Monnett were both listed as "Farmers."  Thomas reported real estate worth $40,000 and personalty worth $500.  I suspect that the $40,000 is an error, inasmuch as nearby farms were not valued over $10,000.  I believe it should be $4,000, the same value he placed on his Ohio farm in 1850.  It is also noted on the 1860 census form that in addition to farming, Thomas Monnett was also a "Missionary."

I was unable to find Elmira Monnett in either the 1870 or 1880 US Censuses.

In 1879 Elmira was reported as attending Indiana Asbury University in Greencastle, Indiana.  Asbury University was founded by the Methodist Church (as was Northwestern University in Evanston) and is now known as DePauw University.

On July 1, 1880, Elmira's mother Mary Delamer Kinnear Monnett died.  She is buried in the Monnett family plot in the Weston Cemetery in Rensselaer, Indiana:

                           Photos by Find a Grave volunteer rschenk

The 1890 US Census entry for Elmira Monnett is of course, lost, however the Evanston City Directory for 1891 lists Elmira Monnett as living at the Avenue House which was at the corner of Davis Street and Chicago Avenue:

  
History does not record why Elmira Monnett came to Evanston in the first place, nor do we know why she decided to get into the hotel business.  But newspaper accounts note that in 1892 she decided that the Avenue House and the Greenwood Inn needed some added competition.  For her hotel she chose a site just up the street from the Avenue House at 1633 Chicago Avenue.  The Hotel Monnett, a four story brick structure opened for business in May of 1894.  Here is an advertisement from the Chicago Inter-Ocean, indicating that the Hotel Monnett had opened for business May 15th:

Advertisements for the Hotel Monnett continued to show up in the Chicago newspapers through the 1890s into 1900 as the hotel became a center of social activity for people affiliated with both Northwestern University and the Woman's Christian Temperance Union:

Here is the Hotel Monnett in its heyday:

Hotel Monnett, 1633 Chicago Avenue, Evanston, Illinois

Strangely, Elmira Monnett shows up in the 1900 US Census not in Evanston, Illinois but in Fairfield, Indiana where she was living at the Stockton House Hotel.  She told the census taker that she could read and write, and that she could speak English but did not list an occupation.  She did, however lie about her age.  She was 57 years old; she admitted to 50.  The 1900 US Census for Evanston, Illinois shows that the Hotel Monnett was being managed by Elmira's brother Fletcher and his wife Mary.  Elmira and her brother were apparently partners in other real estate ventures as well.  It was reported that among other investments, Elmira and Fletcher Monnett owned two large lots in Marion Township, Indiana. 

In 1904 Elmira Monnett made a substantial donation to her alma mater, Indiana Asbury University, now called DePauw University.  The university announced that the Kinnear-Monnett Philosophical Library was established by "Miss Elmira Monnett of Evanston, Illinois, in honor of her parents, and for the special use of students in Philosophy." 

Elmira Monnett died on April 27, 1907 in Rensselaer, Indiana after she had suffered a massive stroke. Here is her death certificate:

Here is her Death Notice from the Munster (Ind.) Times April 29, 1907:

Elmira Monnett was buried in the Weston Cemetery in Rensselaer in her family's plot:

Whether he had been an original investor or not we do not know, but we do know that after the death of his sister, Fletcher Monnett took over sole ownership of the Hotel Monnett.

As indicated above, Fletcher Monnett was born in 1838.  The 1860 US Census showed him living at home with his parents and assisting his father with farming.  Unlike his sisters who never married, on May 14, 1863 Fletcher Monnett married Mary Ellen Chesnut (1842-1905) in Clermont, Ohio.  The groom was 24 years old; the bride was 20.  The newlyweds settled in Rensselaer, Indiana where Fletcher took a job as the US Postmaster on November 30, 1864.

Fletcher and Mary Ellen Monnett had three children:  Ida Jane (1864-1937), Ellen Delamer (1865-1937) and Charles Officer Monnett (1869-1890).

I could not find the Fletcher Monnett family in the 1870 US Census but by 1880 they were living in Urbana, Illinois where Fletcher reported his occupation as "Grocer."  Mary Ellen's mother Jane Officer Chesnut (1807-1891) was living with them.

We do not have the 1890 US Census for the Monnett family, but 1890 was not a good year for Fletcher Monnett.  On February 9, 1890 Fletcher's father Thomas Monnett died, followed by Fletcher's son Charles who died on August 29, 1890.  Both were buried in the Monnett family plot in Weston Cemetery. 

As indicated above, by the time of the 1900 US Census Fletcher  and his wife were living in Evanston where he was managing the hotel for his sister.  Their daughters were adults by this time and had moved out on their own but Fletcher and Mary Ellen were living at the Hotel Monnett. Fletcher's wife Mary Ellen Chesnut Monnett died on March 21, 1905 in Evanston.  Here is her Death Notice from the Jasper County (Ind.) Democrat from March 25, 1905:

On March 23, 1905 she was buried in the Monnett family plot in the Weston Cemetery:

The death first of his wife Mary in March of 1905, and then his sister Elmira in April of 1907 put a terrible strain on the shoulders of Fletcher Monnett.  He had been dealing with heart trouble for years and the stress of running a hotel coupled with everything else that was happening in his life began to catch up with him and his health began to fail.  Then in 1908 came the straw that broke the camel's back - from his sister Cordellia.Deaconess Cordellia Monnett, referred to in the press as a "wealthy spinster" had told her brother Fletcher on many occasions that she was leaving her home, her investments, and considerable land holdings she owned, to him and to his daughters  Ida Jane (Mrs. H.P. Burton) and Ellen (Mrs. H.L. Brown).  Imagine their shock when it was announced in the press in January of 1908 that Deaconness Cordellia had decided to leave it all to the Methodist Church - specifically to the Chicago Training School for City, Home, and Foreign Missions.  Her beautiful home was to be used as a home for wayward girls, and the remainder of the gift could be used in any way the Church chose, except that a building was to be erected at the settlement in Chicago dedicated to her late mother Mary Delamer Kinnear Monnett. In exchange for this, the Church would allow Cordellia to live at the Training School in Chicago, provide a trained nurse to be with her at all times, and also provide an annuity of $2,000 per year for the remainder of her life.Fletcher and his daughters felt that the Methodist Church had exerted undue influence on Cordellia and immediately filed suit to nullify the gifts. To avoid protracted litigation and considerable legal fees that would have to be paid by both sides, Cordellia and Fletcher came to an out-of-court settlement in February of 1908, basically dividing Cordellia's holdings in two - half for Fletcher and his daughters and half for the Church.  Cordellia Monnett died in 1910 at the age of 73.  Not surprisingly, she is not buried in the Monnett family plot in the Weston Cemetery, she is buried in Forest Home Cemetery in Forest Park, Illinois in the Methodist Episcopal Deaconess plot. 

All of the stress of the previous few years finally got to Fletcher and his health began to fail.  He was still living at the Hotel Monnett in Evanston and remained there for his convalescence.  During this time he was nursed by another resident of the hotel, Mrs. Elizabeth G. Frame Libby (1853-1941), the widow of Miltimore Watts "Milton" Libby (1852-1896).  She was referred to in the press as "Lida Libby."  Here is the announcement of their marriage from the Chicago Tribune of March 17, 1909:

In May of 1909 Fletcher Monnett sold the Hotel Monnett to Mrs. Lillian Davidson, so after their honeymoon the newlyweds settled in Rensselaer, Indiana, where Fletcher had lived before he moved to Evanston to help run the Hotel Monnett.

Fletcher Monnett's happiness was short-lived however and he died in Rensselaer, Indiana on July 12, 1910.  Here is his Death Certificate:

and his death notice from the Evanston Index of July 30, 1910:

Fletcher Monnett was, of course, buried in the Monnett family plot in the Weston Cemetery, next to his first wife and son:

This article is supposed to be about the Hotel Monnett and its ownership by the Monnett Family, but I will give you a short summary of the "rest of the story."  

As mentioned above, the Hotel Monnett was purchased by Lillian Davidson (1865-1934) in May of 1909.  

Lillian Davidson

In her later years she turned the management of the hotel over to her son-in-law Wayland L. Cocroft (1876-1948), who continued to manage the hotel after Lillian Davidson's death at the hotel in 1934.  The hotel stayed in the family until it was sold in 1944 by the State National Bank and Trust Company as Trustee for the Davidson-Cocroft family to an investment client of Hokanson and Jenks Realtors who planned to raze the hotel as soon as the war ban on construction was lifted. 

The Hotel Monnett was razed in 1945 and a grocery store was built in its place.

 Hotel Monnett, Evanston, Illinois (1894-1945)